
傍晚的時候和我娘出去散佈, 當我們經過Granville上的電影院時, 那裡站在門口的員工塞給我兩張門票, 原來是過兩天要上映的新電影 My Sister's Keeper, 台灣應該翻 "姊姊的守護者". 老早就想看Jodi Picoult的原著, 可惜當時在誠品的時候選擇把書錢花在Phillipe Gregory的歷史小說上~~~ 前一陣子看到小說已翻拍成電影也蠻想去看看的, 現在有免費的招待怎麼能不接受呢?
11歲的Anna自小就為了得了癌症的姊姊Kate捐贈許多身體的部分. 不只是這樣, Anna的出生其實就是父母為了救姊姊而安排的, 連基因也是經過特別調整過的, 為了就是要符合捐增條件. 不管是骨髓, 血液, 還是內臟, 許多她有的都為了治姊姊的病而分給Kate. 某一天當她的姊姊突然病發而急需一個腎臟, 可想而知捐贈者自然就是Anna. 就在這緊急的時刻, 姊妹的父母突然接到被告通知, 原告竟然就是自己的小女兒, Anna自稱自己已經無法在忍耐長期住院, 忍受刀割, 和父母對她的要求, 並且請了律師幫她爭取自己的醫療監管權. 於是全家人長久以來被壓抑的無奈就在這個時候爆發出來了~
一開始只是以為妹妹是一時堵氣才不肯捐贈腎臟救姊姊的, 覺得難以至信, 畢竟姊妹看起來真的很愛對方. 其實看到最後的人都知道其實不完全是這個原因. 但我覺得更重要的是倫理問題. 雖然未成年的孩子是在父母的監管權之下, 但父母就能夠隨意騙騙她說要去買糖果, 結果反而是送進手術室去把一塊內臟割出來嗎? 有一幕是姊妹的爸爸回想當時把不停哭鬧的五歲妹妹抱進手術室, 然後被醫生壓在台上並且強行麻醉. 就算是為了救姊姊, 但其實不管誰看到這裡應該會感覺很心疼吧. 何況, 雖然妹妹的怨言不多, 但父母依然把注意力都放在生病的姊姊上, 所以給予哥哥和妹妹的愛護並不多.
片中的溫馨畫面也不少. 像是姊姊和她同樣是癌症患者的男友約會時的那一段, 雖然兩個都是病人, 但看他們能夠扶持對方像是比誰都堅強. 家人大大小小窩在病房吃Pizza, 全家人去Santa Monica照相,.. 這一系列的畫面恐怕讓在場的所有觀眾想到 "活著真好, 有家人真好" 吧. 片中也慘雜了許多幽默有趣的地方, 有這些元素讓這較悲哀的電影打了止痛針.
唯一我無法認可的就是這不電影改了最不該改的結局 (Spoilers)
小說裡的結局是, 最後妹妹雖然贏了官司, 但不久卻死於車禍. 擁有妹妹醫療監護權的律師決定把妹妹的腎臟捐給姊姊, 並且讓姊姊康復. 電影裡面死的卻是姊姊. 雖然電影想要強調妹妹擁有了自己的醫療監護權, 才讓姊姊的死來成全這一點, 但難道妹妹是真心不想救姊姊嗎? 倫理上來說, 能夠爭取到自己的醫療監護權已經在法律上得到認可, 我不覺得這點一定要延伸到犧牲妹妹的心意和姊姊的生命的地步. 妹妹真正希望的不就是想做姊姊永遠的守護者嗎?
演員上來說~ 36歲Cameron雖然升格演媽媽了, 但還是好美 T_T
童星Abigail Breslin 從Definitely, Maybe時就覺得她不比Dakota Fanning遜色
新人Thomas Dekker很熱 Whooooooo
It's a bit frightening if I think about it, I mean, I've been watching Japanese dramas since I was 7 but they had all been popular dramas. Atsuhime (2008) is actually my first NHK Taiga drama. I thought there would be a lot of dragging and sope opera characteristics since it's such a long drama, but really, the story is complicated and once you leave the screen for two seconds you won't be able to catch up to the plot I never knew Taiga dramas can be so exciting!
Atsuhime is the 47th Taiga drama which was broadcasted throughout 2008. While it was still airing in Japan, it had already made some noise around Asia, at least it got to me. The lead actress Miyazaki Aoi suddenly became a popular figure in Japan (also due to her wedding) and I believe the drama also boosted the tourism industry for Tenshoin Atsuhime's museum and her birth place in Satsuma, Kagoshima. I remember last year the J-pop section on News sites are filled by this Atsuhime trend. It was craaaaazy.
So Atsuhime....She was the wife of the 13th Shogun of Tokugawa - Tokugawa Iesada. Born 1835 in Kagoshima to a family of Shimazu clan; I guess they're some noble division? She had a dramatic life, first travelling to Edo, then married a Shogun, later was heavily involved in political events during the Meiji Restoration and died at the age of 48.







